Blog

If you have kids, you have probably thought about how to give them a financial head start. The good news is that there are several solid options available to you. The less good news is that they each come with trade-offs, and picking the right one depends on your goals, your child's situation, and how much control you want to maintain over the money.

A lot of parents don't realize that setting up an investment or retirement account for their child is not as simple as setting up an account in the child's name and then contributing money. Minor children under age 18 cannot directly own banking or investment accounts. Because of this, parent-owned accounts or custodial accounts are generally the path to setting aside money for your children.

There is more than one way to do this, but as you might expect, each path has pros and cons.  

The Custodial Roth IRA

A Custodial Roth IRA is, without question, one of the most powerful financial tools available for a child who has earned income. The tax advantages alone make it worth serious consideration.

Here is how it works: a parent or guardian opens and manages the account on behalf of the minor (typically called a custodial Roth IRA). When the child reaches adulthood (typically age 18 or 21, depending on the state), control of the account transfers to them. Contributions are made with after-tax dollars, the money grows completely tax-free, and qualified withdrawals in retirement are also tax-free.

Think about what that means over time. A child who starts contributing at age 14 has potentially 50-plus years of tax-free compounding ahead of them. Even a modest annual contribution can grow into a significant sum by the time they retire.

The long time horizon, combined with tax-free growth, makes this account particularly attractive. 

The Earned Income Requirement

There is one important catch with a Custodial Roth IRA: your child must have earned income to contribute. This means income from actual work, such as wages from a job, self-employment income, or money earned from a legitimate business activity. Allowance does not count. Gifts do not count. Investment income does not count.

The annual contribution limit is the lesser of the IRS Roth IRA limit for the year or the child's total earned income for the year. So if your child earned $3,000 mowing lawns or working a part-time job, they can contribute up to $3,000 to their Custodial Roth IRA.

One nuance worth knowing: the parent can make the contribution on the child's behalf. The child does not need to physically deposit their own paycheck. As long as the contribution does not exceed what the child earned, you can fund the account for them.

This requirement makes the Custodial Roth IRA most accessible for teenagers with jobs, children who work in a family business, or young people with any form of verifiable income.

Pros and Cons of the Custodial Roth IRA

Advantages:

• Tax-free growth and tax-free qualified withdrawals in retirement
• An exceptionally long compounding runway for a young person
• Contributions (not earnings) can be withdrawn at any time without penalty, offering some flexibility
• No required minimum distributions

Disadvantages:

• Requires earned income, which limits who qualifies
• Annual contribution limits are relatively low
• Control transfers to the child at adulthood, regardless of financial maturity

UTMA and UGMA Accounts

UTMA (Uniform Transfers to Minors Act) and UGMA (Uniform Gifts to Minors Act) accounts are custodial accounts that allow adults to hold and manage investments for a minor child without the earned income requirement. These are general investment accounts, not retirement accounts, so there are no contribution limits and no restrictions on what the money can eventually be used for.

As the custodian, you manage the account until the child reaches the age of majority in your state, which is typically 18 or 21. At that point, the assets legally transfer to the child with no strings attached.

The Advantages of UTMA/UGMA Accounts

These accounts are relatively simple to open and come with broad investment flexibility. You can hold stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and other securities. There is no earned income requirement, no contribution limit, and no restriction on what the funds are ultimately used for. The money can go toward college, a car, a business, travel, or anything else.

The Downside (Loss of Control)

Here is the issue that causes many parents to pause: once your child reaches the age of majority, they gain complete, irrevocable control over the account. You cannot delay the transfer. You cannot add conditions. The money is theirs to do with as they please.

For some families, this is fine. For others, the idea of handing a large sum of money to an 18-year-old with no guardrails is unsettling. If your child is not yet financially mature, this can become a real problem. The account assets legally belong to the child from the moment of contribution, meaning the transfer at adulthood is guaranteed regardless of the circumstances.

There is also a financial aid impact worth knowing about. UTMA and UGMA assets are counted as student assets on the FAFSA, which can reduce aid eligibility more significantly than parental assets would.

Pros and Cons of UTMA/UGMA Accounts

Advantages:

• No earned income requirement
• No contribution limits
• Flexible investment options
• No restrictions on how the funds are used

Disadvantages:

• Child gains full, irrevocable control at the age of majority
• Assets count as student assets on FAFSA, potentially reducing financial aid
• Investment gains are subject to capital gains taxes
• Once assets are contributed, they cannot be taken back

A Brokerage Account in the Parent's Name (But Earmarked for the Child)

This option does not have an official name or a tax advantage attached to it, but for many parents it ends up being the most practical and flexible choice available.

The concept is simple: you open a standard taxable brokerage account in your own name and invest money you intend to eventually pass along to your child. You might mentally earmark it for them or even label it in the account description online as being "for" your child, but legally, it remains your account under your control.

Why This Often The Ideal Solution

The key advantage here is control. You decide when to give the money to your child, how much, and under what circumstances. If your child turns 22 and is making responsible financial decisions, you give them the funds. If they are not quite there yet, you wait. If they need money for a down payment on a home at 30, you can transfer it then. You are not locked into any timeline.

This approach also sidesteps the age-of-majority handover problem that comes with UTMA and UGMA accounts. There is no mandatory transfer. The money is yours until you choose to give it.

From an investment standpoint, a taxable brokerage account gives you the same broad range of options as any other account. You can invest in index funds, ETFs, individual stocks, and more. You will pay capital gains taxes on gains when you sell, but with thoughtful investing and tax-efficient fund selection, this is very manageable.

The Gift Tax Concern

Many parents wonder whether giving money to their children triggers a tax obligation. The short answer for the vast majority of people is no, it does not create a real tax problem.

Here is how the rules work. The IRS allows each person to give up to a certain amount per recipient per year without any gift tax filing requirement. That means you can give your child up to the annual limit each year, and your spouse can give another sum up to the annual exclusion per year with no reporting required whatsoever (look up the annual gift tax exclusion for the specific tax year that relates to you).

But even if you exceed the annual exclusion, that does not necessarily mean you owe gift tax. Amounts above the annual exclusion simply count against your lifetime gift and estate tax exemption, which is in the millions per individual (look up the specific figures for the year you are in). Most people never come close to exhausting this exemption over their lifetimes.

In practical terms, gifting investment money to your child at almost any scale is unlikely to create a real tax burden for the average family. Your financial advisor or tax professional can help you navigate the specific numbers if you have concerns.

Pros and Cons of a Parent's Brokerage Account

Advantages:

• Complete flexibility over timing and amount of any gift to your child
• No mandatory transfer at any age
• Same broad investment options as any brokerage account
• Gift tax concerns are minimal for most families, given annual and lifetime exclusions
• You retain the ability to use the funds yourself if circumstances change

Disadvantages:

• No specific tax advantages tied to the account
• Capital gains are taxable to the parent
• Requires discipline to actually follow through on gifting the funds

The Trump Account

The Trump Account, formally introduced as part of recent legislative efforts, is a new type of savings vehicle designed for newborn children. The most notable feature is a one-time $1,000 seed contribution from the federal government for eligible newborns, intended to give every child a starting point for long-term savings.

The account functions somewhat similarly to a Traditional IRA. However, contributions made using after-tax dollars have the potential for tax-advantaged growth over time. Families and other individuals can make additional contributions beyond the initial government deposit.

My Take on the Trump Account

If your child qualifies for the $1,000 government seed contribution, that is a meaningful benefit worth taking advantage of. Free money with the potential to compound over decades is worth taking advantage of.

Beyond that initial deposit, however, the Trump Account does not offer compelling advantages over the other options discussed here. The Custodial Roth IRA provides stronger tax benefits for children with earned income. A parent-owned brokerage account offers more flexibility and control. UTMA and UGMA accounts have fewer restrictions and a longer track record.

The Trump Account is still an evolving program, and the details may change as legislation moves forward. For now, I would treat it as a supplemental option worth considering primarily for families who qualify for that initial $1,000, rather than as a standalone strategy that replaces the other vehicles.

Which Option Is Right for Your Family?

There is no single answer that works for every family, but here is how I generally think about it.

If your child has earned income, a Custodial Roth IRA could be your first move. The tax-free growth over a long time horizon is an advantage that is very difficult to replicate elsewhere. Even small annual contributions can make a significant difference by the time your child reaches retirement age.

If your child does not have earned income and you want a simple, flexible account that grows over time, a UTMA or UGMA account may be worth considering under certain circumstances. Just go in with clear eyes about the age-of-majority transfer and think about whether your child will be ready for that responsibility.

For most parents who want to invest for their child over the long term while maintaining control over when and how the money is transferred, a brokerage account in your own name is often the most practical approach. You can invest the same way, gift the money on your own timeline, and avoid the complications that come with mandatory account transfers at a fixed age.

The Trump Account is worth exploring if your newborn qualifies for the government seed contribution, but it should generally be considered alongside the other options rather than instead of them.

As always, the right plan is one that you will actually follow through on. Working with a financial advisor who understands your full picture can help you make the most of whichever approach you choose.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I open a Custodial Roth IRA for my child if they only do occasional odd jobs?

Yes, as long as the income is legitimate and documented. Self-employment income from lawn mowing, babysitting, or other informal work counts as earned income. Keep records of what was paid and when. The contribution cannot exceed what your child actually earned during the year.

What happens to a Custodial Roth IRA when my child turns 18?

The account transfers to your child's full control. At that point, it becomes a standard Roth IRA in their name. They can continue contributing, leave the money invested, or make withdrawals subject to the usual Roth IRA rules.

Can I contribute to both a Custodial Roth IRA and a UTMA account for the same child?

Yes. These are separate accounts with different rules, and there is nothing preventing you from using both simultaneously. Some parents use a Custodial Roth IRA for long-term retirement savings and a UTMA account for money that might be used sooner.

Do I have to file a gift tax return if I give my child money?

You are required to file IRS Form 709 if you give any single recipient more than the annual exclusion amount in a given year. However, filing a return does not necessarily mean you owe tax. Amounts above the annual exclusion simply reduce your lifetime exemption. For the vast majority of families, gift taxes are not a real concern.

Can a grandparent contribute to any of these accounts?

Yes. Grandparents can contribute to Custodial Roth IRAs (as long as the child has earned income), UTMA and UGMA accounts, and can make gifts from their own brokerage accounts as well. The same annual gift tax exclusion applies to each donor.

What is the best investment to hold inside these accounts?

For long time horizons, low-cost, diversified index funds or ETFs are generally a strong choice. They provide broad market exposure, minimize fees, and tend to outperform more complex strategies over time. Talk to your financial advisor about the specific options available within the account type you choose.

Is a brokerage account in my name the same as a trust?

No. A trust is a separate legal entity with its own rules and administrative requirements. A brokerage account in your own name is simply an account you own. It does not carry the legal protections or formality of a trust. If you want more structured control over how and when assets are distributed to your child, a trust may be worth exploring with an estate planning attorney.

How do I actually get started?

Start by identifying which option fits your situation: does your child have earned income? How much control do you want to retain? What is your timeline? From there, most major brokerage firms allow you to open Custodial Roth IRAs and UTMA/UGMA accounts online. A regular brokerage account in your own name can be opened the same way.

Working with a financial advisor can help you coordinate the account with your broader financial plan.