Blog

As you approach age 65, one of the most important—and often confusing—financial decisions you face is how to structure your Medicare coverage. Understanding the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans is essential for making an informed decision that aligns with your healthcare needs, financial situation, and lifestyle.

Let’s break it down clearly so you can avoid common pitfalls and plan confidently.

What Is Medicare?

Medicare is the national health insurance program for people aged 65 and older. It includes:

• Part A: Hospital insurance
• Part B: Medical insurance
• Part D: Prescription drug coverage

Original Medicare is managed by the federal government. It works with any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare and was designed as a payment system—not a care delivery system. In contrast, Medicare Advantage (also known as Part C) is offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare to provide Part A and B coverage, often bundling in Part D and other benefits.

The Initial Fork in the Road

When someone first enrolls in Medicare, they face a critical decision: Original Medicare with supplemental coverage, or a Medicare Advantage plan?

Original Medicare Path:

• Enroll in Parts A and B
• Add a Medigap (supplemental) policy to cover costs Medicare doesn’t pay
• Add a standalone Part D drug plan
• Greater flexibility with providers
• No network restrictions

Medicare Advantage Path:

• One plan usually bundles Parts A, B, and D
• Often includes extras like vision, dental, and gym memberships
• Lower premiums, sometimes even zero
• Managed care network (HMO or PPO)
• Potential for limited access to specialists and care outside local areas

Common Misconceptions

Many people mistakenly believe Medicare Advantage is the only way to get Medicare because of aggressive advertising, especially during open enrollment. These ads often downplay limitations, such as network restrictions or prior authorizations.

It’s important to note that Original Medicare is still available and often better suited to those who travel or need specialized care.

Pros and Cons at a Glance

Why Choose Original Medicare?

• Freedom of choice: See any provider nationwide who accepts Medicare.
• Stable benefits: Medigap policies don’t change annually.
• Predictable costs: With a comprehensive Medigap plan like Plan G, out-of-pocket expenses are minimal.
• No prior authorizations: Less red tape when seeking care.

Why Choose Medicare Advantage?

• Lower or zero premiums
• Bundled benefits: Dental, vision, hearing, sometimes Part B premium rebates
• Convenience: One plan handles everything
• Attractive to healthy individuals: Especially appealing if care usage is minimal

For individuals who travel frequently within the United States, there are important differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans to consider.

Original Medicare offers nationwide access to care, allowing beneficiaries to see any doctor or specialist in the U.S. who accepts Medicare. This makes it particularly well-suited for those with multiple residences or who spend significant time away from home.

There are no network restrictions, so you're not limited by geographic location, and most services do not require prior authorization, making it easier to receive care while on the road.

In contrast, Medicare Advantage plans often have regional provider networks. If you're outside of your plan’s service area, you may not be covered for non-emergency care, which can be a major drawback for frequent travelers.

While some Medicare Advantage PPO plans do allow for out-of-network care, it typically comes with higher out-of-pocket costs. Regular travel outside your home area can complicate care access and potentially result in unexpected expenses.

For these reasons, Original Medicare combined with a Medigap policy is generally a better fit for those who need the flexibility to access healthcare services across the country.

The Risk of Starting with Medicare Advantage

Here’s the catch: switching from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare later can be tricky. You might not qualify for a Medigap policy if your health has declined because insurers can deny coverage based on medical underwriting—unless you're in the six-month Medigap open enrollment period.

This means that while Medicare Advantage may be cheaper upfront, it can lead to higher long-term costs and limited access to care if serious health issues arise. It’s a gamble, and many people end up regretting it.

And remember that while it can be tempting to choose a plan based on the fact that you are healthy and don't utilize a lot of health care services, that can change at any time. It's difficult to predict how your health may change in the future.

Understanding Medigap

Medigap policies help cover costs not paid by Original Medicare, such as coinsurance and deductibles. The most comprehensive currently available to new enrollees is Plan G.

Key points of Medigap:

• Premiums vary widely by location and insurer.
• Once purchased, benefits remain the same as long as premiums are paid.
• Policies don’t cover vision, dental, hearing aids, or care outside the U.S.
• Medigap policies are standardized, making price comparison straightforward.

The Medicare Advantage Trade-Off

Medicare Advantage plans operate on one-year contracts. Benefits and provider networks can change yearly. If Medicare cuts payments to these private plans (as has been discussed), insurers may react by:

• Narrowing networks
• Reducing benefits
• Increasing out-of-pocket costs

These plans are profitable for insurers, which incentivizes heavy promotion. Brokers often receive higher commissions for Medicare Advantage sales, which can influence recommendations.

Cost Comparison*

Original Medicare:

• Part B premium ($174.70 in 2024, plus any IRMAA)
• Medigap premiums (around $160–$230/month)
• Part D premium (as low as $0.50/month)
• Predictable, capped costs (if Plan G is selected)

Medicare Advantage:

• Part B premium still applies
• Many plans have $0 additional premiums
• Cost-sharing at the point of care
• Annual out-of-pocket max ($4,000–$9,000)

Key Enrollment Timelines

• Initial Enrollment Period: Starts 3 months before turning 65 and ends 3 months after
• Medigap Open Enrollment: 6 months after enrolling in Part B
• Annual Enrollment Period (AEP): October 15 – December 7, to review or change plans
• Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment: January 1 – March 31, to switch or return to Original Medicare (with some restrictions)

Choosing the Right Medicare Plan

Keep in mind these key points to avoid costly mistakes:

• Research options early 
• Make sure you understand the irreversible nature of some decisions
• Look for unbiased resources like Medicare.gov
• Understand the long-term benefits of flexibility and comprehensive coverage

Medicare is one of the best health insurance programs available, and it's a fantastic benefit available when you turn 65. Be sure to research your options carefully so you have the right plan in place for your health care needs.

*Costs are current as of 2025