Blog

Investing often feels like walking a tightrope between risk and reward. Everyone wants the growth potential of stocks, but not everyone is comfortable with the possibility of steep losses. That’s where buffered ETFs come in — a type of investment designed to offer some downside protection while still allowing for market participation.

If you’re someone looking for a middle ground between aggressive stock investments and ultra-conservative bonds, buffered ETFs could be worth understanding. Let’s dive into what they are, how they work, and when they might make sense in your portfolio.

What Is a Buffered ETF?

A buffered ETF (also known as a defined outcome ETF) is an exchange-traded fund that attempts to limit the downside losses in a market while capping the upside gains.

Essentially, these ETFs promise to "buffer" or protect against a certain percentage of losses—typically between 10% and 30%—over a specified period, usually one year. However, in exchange for this protection, your potential gains are also capped.

The goal is simple: soften the blow during market downturns while still capturing some of the market’s upward movement.

Buffered ETFs are created using options strategies, primarily buying and selling options on an underlying index like the S&P 500.

While they are not risk-free, they are engineered to provide a smoother ride for investors who are nervous about volatility but still want to be in the market.

How Buffered ETFs Work

To understand how buffered ETFs work, it’s helpful to think about the two key components: the buffer and the cap.

The Buffer

The buffer is the percentage of loss that the ETF protects against. For example, a buffered ETF with a 10% buffer will absorb the first 10% of losses during the outcome period.

If the market drops 8%, you would likely experience no loss at all. If the market drops 15%, you might see a loss of around 5% (the amount beyond the 10% buffer).

Different ETFs offer different buffer levels, so it’s important to know the specific protection you're getting.

The Cap

The cap is the maximum return you can earn during the outcome period.

Since the ETF provides downside protection, it needs to offset the cost of that protection by limiting how much you can gain. If the market gains 20% but your ETF has a 9% cap, you’ll only realize that 9% gain, not the full market return.

Caps can fluctuate based on market conditions, interest rates, and volatility when the fund’s outcome period begins.

The Outcome Period

Most buffered ETFs have a specific time frame, typically one year, known as the outcome period.

Your buffer and cap are designed to work over this set period. If you buy the ETF at the beginning of the outcome period and hold it to the end, you’ll experience the full intended buffer and cap effects.

If you buy midway through or sell early, your experience could be different.

What Happens to Returns Above the Cap in a Buffered ETF?

If the market outperforms the cap during the outcome period, investors in the buffered ETF do not receive any additional returns above the cap. Instead, all gains above the cap are effectively "given up" as part of the trade-off for the downside protection.

How This Works Mechanically:

• The ETF achieves the cap by selling call options on the reference index. A call option is a financial contract that gives the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to purchase an underlying asset at a specified price within a certain time frame. The premium collected from selling these calls helps fund the purchase of put options for downside protection. A put option is a financial contract that gives the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to sell an underlying asset at a specified price within a certain time frame.
• If the underlying index rises above the cap, the sold call options are exercised by the counterparty, so the ETF does not participate in gains above the cap.
• The additional returns above the cap go to the buyers of the call options sold by the ETF, not to the ETF shareholders.

Why Investors Use Buffered ETFs

Buffered ETFs can appeal to investors who are looking for a compromise between full market exposure and complete safety.

If you're worried about a market correction but don't want to sit in cash or bonds, a buffered ETF might allow you to stay invested with a bit more peace of mind.

They can also be useful for specific goals, such as:

• Protecting a portion of your retirement savings as you near retirement.
• Allocating a more conservative portion of an otherwise aggressive portfolio.
• Participating in market gains without exposure to full market losses.

However, they’re not a magic solution. You still bear some risk, especially if markets fall beyond the buffer or if you don’t hold the ETF for the full outcome period.

Pros and Cons of Buffered ETFs

It’s important to understand both the advantages and limitations of buffered ETFs before investing.

Pros

• Downside protection: Shields against a set amount of loss.
• Market participation: Offers the potential for higher gains compared to staying in cash.
• Simplicity: Easier to understand and access compared to creating your own options strategy.
• Transparency: Most buffered ETFs clearly state their buffer and cap levels.

Cons

• Capped returns: Limits your potential gains in strong bull markets.
• Complexity: Though simpler than options trading, they are more complex than traditional ETFs.
• Timing matters: Entering or exiting outside of the intended period can alter the expected outcomes.
• Costs: Buffered ETFs often carry higher expense ratios than typical index funds.

When Might a Buffered ETF Make Sense for You?

Buffered ETFs aren’t for everyone, but they can make a lot of sense depending on your situation and goals.

You might consider a buffered ETF if:

• You're approaching a major life event, like retirement, and want to reduce portfolio volatility.
• You are generally risk-averse but don't want to miss out on all stock market gains.
• You believe markets may be volatile or flat in the near future, but still want some exposure.
• You’re building a diversified strategy that blends growth and protection.

However, if you have a long time horizon and can tolerate short-term volatility, traditional stock funds might still be the better option.

Things to Watch Out For

Before investing in a buffered ETF, there are some important factors to evaluate:

• Understand the exact buffer and cap: They differ from fund to fund and period to period.
• Check the outcome period dates: Buying at the wrong time can dramatically change your returns.
• Know the costs: Look at expense ratios and any embedded fees.
• Make sure it fits your overall plan: Buffered ETFs should serve a specific role in your portfolio, not be the entire strategy.

It’s often a good idea to consult a financial advisor who can help you decide if a buffered ETF aligns with your broader investment plan.

Final Thoughts

Buffered ETFs offer a compelling tool for investors who want to soften the risk of stock market investing without giving up on growth entirely.

While they aren't a substitute for a well-diversified portfolio, they can play an important role in certain strategies, especially when market conditions seem volatile or when protecting principal becomes a bigger priority.

As with any investment, the key is understanding exactly how it works — and making sure it fits your long-term financial goals.